Private School vs Public School: Which Option is Right For Your Child in 2024?

As parents, we all want the best for our children, especially when it comes to their education.

But choosing the right education option for your child can be a daunting task. With so many options available to parents, it can be challenging to know which one is the best fit for your child.

The decision you make can impact not only your child’s academic progress but also their social interactions and personal development. 

So it’s a pretty big decision. 

But don’t fret—we’re going to cover the ins and outs of two of the most common options (public school and private school) available in your state. Plus, we’ll cover an amazing third option (microschools!). 

By the end of this blog, you should have everything you need to make an informed decision about your child’s education. 

Let’s get started. 

What is the difference between private and public schools in the United States? 

The primary difference between private and public schools in the U.S. is the funding source.

How are public schools funded? 

Public schools are operated by the state education department and funded with tax dollars. 

Some of these funds come from state taxes, and some come from federal taxes. This means that your local public school is responsible for adhering to the regulations set forth by your state department of education and any legislation at the federal level that is tied to accepting specific funding streams. 

These regulations include not teaching religious curriculum, participating in standardized testing, and ensuring that students at specific grade levels are exposed to specific standardized content. These standards and regulations are in place to guarantee that every child can access a quality education as defined by the government. 

The school district creates school boundary lines and decides which neighborhoods will be assigned to specific schools. Unless you live in a state with an “open enrollment” law, your kids will attend the public school they are assigned to. 

A private school exists completely outside of the public education system. They do not accept public funds and, therefore, do not have to comply with the educational regulations that follow public funding. They do not serve a specific location, and families typically have to apply and be accepted. The private school is allowed to decide who attends their school as long as they aren’t discriminating based on things like race. They also have complete control over what is taught and how it is taught. Private school students do not sit for state standardized tests. Private schools do not have to provide special education services if they don’t want to, but many do. 

Some states require private schools to be “accredited,” which means that a trusted third-party evaluator has reviewed and approved their learning approach and management procedures. 

Private vs. public schools: which education is better? 

So which education option is better?

The short answer is: it depends.

It all comes down to what you are looking for when it comes to an education option for your child.

Remember, the common differentiator of these choices is funding. 

But there are some things to consider. 

For example, private schools often have higher average test scores due to smaller class sizes and additional resources. 

Both school types offer extracurriculars, but private schools may provide more specialized programs due to better funding.

Another thing to consider is the approach to education. When you choose to enroll your child in a public school or a private school, you are usually choosing a fairly rigid, standardized approach.

If your student thrives in these settings, awesome! But if you are looking for a more individualized approach where your kids don’t have to “fit into the box” necessarily, looking into a more innovative private option is going to be your best bet.

What are the benefits of private school?

There are many benefits to choosing a private school for your child.

One of the greatest benefits is the enhanced individual attention your child can receive. Smaller student-to-teacher ratios in private schools allow for more personalized instruction, potentially benefiting students who thrive with more individualized attention.

Often, private schools also boast advanced programs in arts, science, and technology, supported by facilities funded through higher tuition rates, providing unique learning opportunities only sometimes available in public schools.

Is private school tuition tax deductible?  

Generally, tuition for private schools in the U.S. is not tax-deductible, except under specific circumstances, such as when tuition is paid for special education services, which may qualify as medical expenses.

What are the downsides of private school?

If you are limited to a budget for your child’s education or if you value diversity, private schools may have a few downsides.

First, the cost of private schooling can be prohibitively high, ranging from $10,000 to over $40,000 annually, which can be a significant financial strain for many families.

Secondly, private schools often lack the economic and racial diversity found in public schools, which could limit students' exposure to a broader societal spectrum.

How much do private schools cost, on average?

Tuition varies, but the average cost generally falls between $10,000 and $25,000 per year, with more prestigious institutions charging considerably more.

What are the benefits of public school? 

One of the biggest benefits of public schools? 

It’s always free. 

Public schools are free to attend, providing education without direct charges to families.

Public schools also typically feature a more diverse student body, which can enrich the learning environment by exposing students to various cultural and socioeconomic backgrounds.

What are the downsides of public school? 

Now, let’s talk about the downsides.

Public schools often face challenges such as high student-to-teacher ratios and limited funding, which can impact the quality of education and the amount of individual attention students receive.

Plus, the quality of education in public schools can vary widely depending on the resources of the school district and local funding, leading to disparities in educational outcomes.

What about other approaches to schooling?

As you can see, there are pros and cons to each option. 

But what if there was a third option—an option that blends the socialization benefits of public school with the advantages of small class sizes and individualized attention that private schools may offer?

Well, you’re in luck.

Introducing microschools…  

What is a microschool?

Microschools are tight-knit groups of about 10 kids learning together under the direction of a microschool “guide.” They vary in learning approach and format but are typically personalized and focused on fostering a sense of self-efficacy. Prenda is one of the largest microschool networks in the country and can help you bring a microschool into your community. 

If you want more information about how to find a microschool or, better yet—how to start your own microschool, check out our Microschooling 101 video. 

When microschooling might be right for your child?

So, how do you know if microschooling is right for your child?

Well, consider this—do you want an education option for your child where they get to:

• Learn about topics that interest them?
• Receive personalized attention and a customized learning experience?
• Make projects that bring their learning to life?
• Benefit from a small class size (which reduces social stress and promotes deeper interpersonal relationships!)?
• Acquire social skills such as... collaboration, respect, cooperation, patience, and empathy?
• Discover new concepts by reading interesting books (instead of boring textbooks)
• Learn at their own pace?
• Be seen for who they are (not just what they do or accomplish)?
• Have choices and autonomy?
• Grow academically while having fun?

If you answered yes to any or all of these questions, then microschooling might be the perfect fit for your child.

Microschooling is great for parents, too! 

Microschooling often allows for greater parental input and interaction in the learning process, allowing you to be more directly involved in your child’s education.

Ready for a deep dive into all things microschooling? Take our Beginner’s Guide to Microschooling course.

‍